5263 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242-3319, USA
Mon - Thu : 2:00 PM - 2:00 AMFri - Sun: 12 PM - 2:00 AM

...#PIlife

Our/Yours/Theirs/Mine/TEAM

We could pontificate on how things came to be, how friendships are made and how if once ate one less slice of artisian pizza the world would some how be different.

We could, but we won’t, or at least most of us won’t…

Our diverse team are gather together by the love of laughter, lighthearted and real conversation and a passion for food. We are all here together and it’s hard to find another pizza place on Siesta Key or the greater Sarsota that meets the criteria of the 99% but every day when we win or fail the PI team is right there along side you (and at times in the same boat)!

Our Team

John (L/I)

John (L/I)

Add Current Position
Gino (L/I)

Gino (L/I)

Add Current Position
Ross

Ross

Add Current Position
Jenn  (L/I)

Jenn (L/I)

Add Current Position

Our Happy Guests

Some gathered quotes from the web... We take all of your input, both good, and constructive as we strive to provide the best possible experience!

I moved to Sarasota several years ago and as a new local this one of the locations I always recommend to visitors. This is the local experience. Listen to good music, chat with great people, have good pizza & beer, and enjoy the key. {5-Starts | Google Review}

Sean Altice

Sean Altice

November, 10, 2016

Fab selection of beer and pizza. Super staff – Geno & Jenna especially. It’s our “go to “ place when we are inSiesta Key, consistently good

Paw La

Paw La

January, 22, 2017

My Fiance and I came in with the bridal party the night before the wedding and had one hell of a good time along with superb pizza and phenomenal service. We will definitely go back, highly recommended. {5-Stars | Google Review}

Matthew Nicholas

Matthew Nicholas

I had seen this place pop up on the untapped app several times but had not had the opportunity to visit. Tonight I finally did. Stephanie was the bartender and she made me feel more welcome than I could have ever hoped for. She was knowledgeable, attentive, and polite! I would go back just to see her. Any. Time!

The pizza was very good. Good crust and good toppings. The beer featured rotation taps and was local on the night I was there.

I can’t wait to go back! Worth the trip! {5-Starts | Google Review}

Michael Ludwig

Michael Ludwig

Newsletter